Cats generally don't prefer milk.
As kittens, most mammals, including humans, drink milk produced by their mothers. While it may be thought that cats, like humans, continue drinking milk through adulthood, this assumption is false.
Most cats lose the ability to digest lactose, a kind of sugar in milk, after they stop exclusively drinking maternal milk after weaning—approximately between eight weeks and eleven and a half months of age after birth.
Even in cases where cats can digest lactose as grown individuals, too much ingestion or frequent milk intakes will likely still cause diarrhea due to stomach inflammation.