How Diamond Refutes Cultural Explanations for Domestication Failures

Jared Diamond challenges the idea that failure to domesticate certain animals resulted from cultural differences. He provides several counterexamples:

Similar environments, different outcomes: Different cultural groups in similar environments had varying success domesticating related species—for example, Native Americans did not domesticate the American buffalo, while Eurasians successfully domesticated aurochs and other wild cattle.

Similar selection criteria: Cultures generally used similar criteria for domestication, such as size, behavior, and diet, rather than acting solely on cultural preferences or taboos.

Independent domestication: Species like dogs and horses were domesticated rapidly and independently in multiple regions, suggesting environmental and biological factors mattered more than culture alone.

Diamond acknowledges culture may influence how domesticated animals are used, but he emphasizes environmental constraints and species characteristics as primary factors.