This is a tricky analogy, and the answer depends entirely on which relationship you want to emphasize. Here are the most logical ways to complete the comparison.
Stripes and Family Ties
You could say, "Bull is to elephant as zebra is to horse." Both zebras and horses belong to the same family, and zebras are famous for their stripes.
Shared Ecosystem
Another option is, "Bull is to elephant as zebra is to lion." This connects all four animals to the African savanna ecosystem.
Size Comparison
You might also frame it by size: "Bull is to elephant as zebra is to donkey." Bulls are smaller than elephants, and zebras are generally smaller than donkeys.
Ultimately, there is no single correct answer. The best completion depends on whether you prioritize biology, habitat, or physical characteristics.