Shark attacks in the Great Lakes are extremely rare. There have only been a handful of confirmed attacks in recorded history, most minor and without serious injury.
The 1955 Chicago incident mentioned in newspaper reports likely refers to an event at Jackson Park Beach on July 14, 1955, when a 14-year-old boy was bitten on the leg. Witnesses saw a fish, but it was never confirmed to be a shark. The boy survived, and this remains the only confirmed shark attack in Lake Michigan's history.
Great Lakes waters are generally too cold and lack large shark populations, making attacks minimal risk to swimmers.