There is no reliable way to know exactly how many guinea pigs are in the U.S. There is no central registry tracking ownership, and numbers constantly change due to births, deaths, adoptions, and purchases. Guinea pigs come from pet stores, breeders, shelters, and rescues, making tracking difficult.
However, guinea pigs are very popular pets, and their numbers are likely in the millions—perhaps comparable to other small pets such as rabbits or hamsters.